She Refused To Wear A Black Disney Character’s Bridesmaid Dress Because She Thought It Was Cultural Appropriation – Was She Blowing Things Out Of Proportion?

A lady was friends with a woman named Holly, a devoted Disney enthusiast who had always dreamt of a fairy tale wedding. Holly was soon to be married, yet her innocent dream would soon spark a significant controversy. Here is what she had to say: 

Holly’s Dream

Photo Credit: Roman Samborskyi / Shutterstock.

Holly envisioned herself as a glittering, glamorous princess in a ballgown, surrounded by bridesmaids who would embody Disney princesses in a modern way. Her upcoming summer wedding meant that this dream could finally become a reality.

The Colorful Line-up

Photo Credit: Violator22 / Shutterstock.

For Holly’s wedding, she had a distinct plan in mind. “Holly has chosen Ariel (pink), Cinderella (blue), Belle (yellow), Rapunzel (purple), and Tiana (green)”, Holly’s friend and future bridesmaid explained. 

Assigning Her With Tiana

Photo Credit: fizkes / Shutterstock.

The bridesmaid continued to explain Holly’s decision, including her own personal assignment: “She picked who would be who for us, and told me that she wants me as Tiana since I have black hair”.

A Mismatched Dilemma

Photo Credit: Roman Samborskyi / Shutterstock.

However, the friend took issue with being assigned to dress like Tiana. “The problem is, I’m white, and Tiana is not”, she explained. “The entire bridal party is white. You can see why I’m not feeling this choice.”

Seeking a Resolution

Photo Credit: Roman Samborskyi / Shutterstock.

In an attempt to address her concerns privately, the bridesmaid approached Holly with alternative suggestions for characters with green attire, like Merida or Anna. Unfortunately, Holly dismissed these suggestions, citing Merida’s dress color and Anna’s association with the Frozen franchise as reasons for their unsuitability.

Taking a Stand

Photo Credit: ONB PHOTO / Shutterstock.

Feeling uncomfortable with the choice and unwilling to compromise on her principles, the bridesmaid firmly informed Holly that she would not portray Tiana at the wedding. She offered to consider other options or wait for Holly to provide an alternative, but this did not sit well with the bride-to-be.

The Heated Exchange

Photo Credit: TeodorLazarev / Shutterstock.

Holly’s reaction was not what the bridesmaid had hoped for. Holly resorted to name-calling and accused her friend of being a bad friend and troublemaker for not going along with her vision.

Facing Criticism

Photo Credit: Kamara Studio / Shutterstock.

The bridesmaid soon began receiving messages from Holly’s family and friends, questioning her stance and accusing her of disrupting Holly’s plans. Some fellow bridesmaids even expressed their frustration, urging her to go along with the original choice.

Standing Firm

Photo Credit: Dean Drobot / Shutterstock.

Despite the mounting pressure and criticism, the bridesmaid remained resolute in her decision. She believed that her feelings and concerns were valid, and she didn’t want to compromise her principles or perpetuate a stereotype.

Questioning Her Choice

Photo Credit: Roman Samborskyi / Shutterstock.

However, the pushback that the bridesmaid received made her second-guess her stance. She wondered whether she was making too much of a fuss over what others considered a minor issue.

Asking the Internet

Photo Credit: TimeImage Production / Shutterstock.

The bridesmaid-to-be headed online with her conundrum, writing it up on a community forum for the opinions of others. To the woman’s surprise, everyone believed she was blowing things out of proportion. “I don’t think anyone would be offended if you were dressed as Tiana unless you wore blackface”, one person wrote. “I’m assuming she doesn’t want you to do that.”

Virtue Signalling

Photo Credit: Rawpixel.com / Shutterstock.

A lot of people commented that the bridesmaid’s virtue signaling was the real problem here. “To be honest, I think it’s worse that you’re making such a big deal out of this”, one reader stated. “It really comes off as virtue signaling, as anyone would tell you that it’s okay to dress as a character from a different race as long as you are respectful.”

Opinions From a Black Person 

Photo Credit: Rawpixel.com / Shutterstock.

Even black community members defended Holly’s plans. “I’m saying this as a black woman… you are overreacting”, one member wrote. “If she was asking you to do blackface or something else offensive then I would back you but wearing a modern take on her dress… you can chill out…”

MORE FROM SMART GAMING LAB – A WOMAN MOVING TO ANOTHER STATE AND WAS SHOCKED BY HER MOTHER-IN-LAW’S DEMAND FOR THE RETURN OF HOUSEWARMING GIFTS FROM 16 YEARS AGO, WAS SHE RIGHT TO REFUSE?

Photo Credit: Kues / Shutterstock.com

A woman and her husband moved out of state, but as they were leaving, her mother-in-law asked for the house items back that she had gifted them 16 years ago.

A WOMAN MOVING TO ANOTHER STATE AND WAS SHOCKED BY HER MOTHER-IN-LAW’S DEMAND FOR THE RETURN OF HOUSEWARMING GIFTS FROM 16 YEARS AGO, WAS SHE RIGHT TO REFUSE?

SHE DOESN’T WANT HER HUSBAND’S ELDERLY PARENTS TO MOVE INTO THEIR HOME BUT WHEN SHE DEMANDED HER OWN PARENTS MOVE IN, HER HUSBAND WAS SHOCKED

Photo Credit: Krakenimages/Shutterstock.

A woman recently asked if she was wrong for demanding her own parents move into their home, while refusing to let her husband’s elderly parents have the same right.

SHE DOESN’T WANT HER HUSBAND’S ELDERLY PARENTS TO MOVE INTO THEIR HOME BUT WHEN SHE DEMANDED HER OWN PARENTS MOVE IN, HER HUSBAND WAS SHOCKED

SHE ORDERED HIM TO MOVE HIS CAR AS SHE CALLED DIBS ON THE PARKING SPOT, HE REFUSED TO BACK DOWN

Photo Credit: Roman Samborskyi / Shutterstock.

A man recently turned to the internet for guidance on whether he was in the wrong for not giving up the last available free parking space in a crowded public parking lot to a woman who claimed to have reserved it.

SHE ORDERED HIM TO MOVE HIS CAR AS SHE CALLED DIBS ON THE PARKING SPOT, HE REFUSED TO BACK DOWN

MOTHER DECLINES HER DAUGHTERS REQUEST OF PAYING THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS FOR A COLLEGE EDUCATION AFTER DISPLAYING TOTAL APATHY FOR SCHOOL

Photo Credit: Krakenimages.com / Shutterstock.

A woman sought help online because she wasn’t sure if she was right to refuse to pay for her daughter’s college fees. Her daughter showed zero interest in attending school or participating in anything related to education.

MOTHER DECLINES HER DAUGHTERS REQUEST OF PAYING THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS FOR A COLLEGE EDUCATION AFTER DISPLAYING TOTAL APATHY FOR SCHOOL

A WOMAN AGREED TO GIVE HER FRIEND A LIFT TO AN IMPORTANT JOB INTERVIEW, BUT THE FRIEND INSISTED ON VIOLATING A TRAFFIC REGULATION, WAS THE WOMAN WRONG FOR REFUSING THE RIDE?

Photo Credit: Krakenimages.com / Shutterstock.

A woman in her early twenties agreed to give her new friend a lift to a job interview, but her friend refused to put on a seatbelt – causing an argument that threatened their friendship.

A WOMAN AGREED TO GIVE HER FRIEND A LIFT TO AN IMPORTANT JOB INTERVIEW, BUT THE FRIEND INSISTED ON VIOLATING A TRAFFIC REGULATION, WAS THE WOMAN WRONG FOR REFUSING THE RIDE?

Images are for illustrative purposes only